Student Reflection on "Shoes."

I had my video production class write a reflection on "Shoes," which can be seen on YouTube.com. The project tends to elicit strong reactions, but the reaction I got from one student really stood out:

"First of all I just want to say that I can not believe you made us watch that mess and that I felt like I was getting dumber each second I watched it, so thanks for that. The director did a good job making the video look as dumb as the song sounded. He avoided a few jump cuts by switching from one object to another and then back again. The scenes went with the beat or lack thereof of the song. To me it seemed like the whole video followed all the rules we have discussed in class except maybe that all the shots seemed to be medium shots. I don’t think changing the kinds of shots would have made the video any better though so that doesn’t matter. Since the song was stupid it only made sense that the shots be of stupid things and almost seem to have no order. Especially towards the end it seems as though the shots are just of random things in a random order with no real point to them, just like the song. I have nothing else to say about this assignment because I am still angry that you made us watch this video."